top of page
Writer's pictureMSF

Balancing Tradition and Regulation: The Debate Over Short-Term Rentals in Saratoga Springs

Saratoga Springs, NY, boasts a long-standing tradition of residents renting out their homes to tourists, a practice deeply entrenched in the city's rich history as a favored destination for travelers seeking relaxation, entertainment, and cultural experiences.

However, recent developments have stirred controversy within the community.


On Monday, Moving Saratoga Forward broke the news that the Saratoga Springs City Council is contemplating implementing a series of stringent regulations aimed at making it more challenging for city residents to rent their homes during the tourist season. These regulations include a hefty $1000 fee and regular fire, code, and septic inspections, posing significant hurdles for homeowners looking to exercise their rights to rent their properties.

In this article, we endeavor to provide a balanced perspective on the risks and benefits associated with private home rentals and their impact on the broader community.

Historical Context: Saratoga Springs has been a prominent destination since the 19th century, renowned for its mineral springs, therapeutic baths, and elegant resorts. During the Victorian era, wealthy visitors flocked to Saratoga Springs to enjoy the healing waters and social gatherings, often staying in grand hotels or private residences. The city's tourism industry experienced a significant boost with the establishment of the Saratoga Race Course in the mid-19th century. As the summer racing season gained popularity, local residents began offering accommodations in their homes to accommodate the influx of visitors attending the races. This practice became a lucrative source of income for homeowners, especially during the peak summer months. Over the years, Saratoga Springs has evolved into a year-round tourist destination, attracting visitors with its diverse array of attractions, events, and recreational opportunities. As tourism expanded beyond the racing season to include cultural festivals, outdoor activities, and shopping experiences, the demand for short-term rentals grew accordingly. Home rentals in Saratoga Springs encompass a wide range of properties, including historic homes, cozy cottages, modern apartments, and spacious condos. Homeowners often leverage online platforms like Airbnb or VRBO and rental agencies to advertise their properties to potential guests, offering a personalized and home-like alternative to traditional hotels and resorts.

Benefits?


1. Economic Boost: Renting out homes to tourists provides a valuable source of income for Saratoga Springs residents, allowing them to offset housing costs, generate additional revenue, and support local businesses. Many homeowners view short-term rentals as a way to share their community with visitors while contributing to the local economy.


Additionally, Short-term rentals can provide a significant economic boost to a city by attracting tourists who spend money on accommodations, dining, shopping, and entertainment. This infusion of tourism dollars can support local businesses and stimulate economic growth.

A. Study by Ernst & Young: EY conducted a study commissioned by Airbnb, titled "The Economic Impacts of Home Sharing in Cities" in 2017. The study examined the economic contributions of Airbnb in 12 cities worldwide. It found that Airbnb generated significant economic benefits, including supporting local jobs, boosting small business activity, and generating tax revenue for local governments. For example, in New York City, Airbnb hosts contributed an estimated $632 million to the local economy in 2016.

B. Study by Oxford Economics: Oxford Economics conducted a study commissioned by Airbnb in 2017, titled "Airbnb's Wider Impacts on City Economies." The study analyzed the economic contributions of Airbnb in 10 cities across Europe, including Barcelona, London, Paris, and Rome. It found that Airbnb supported local economic growth by creating opportunities for micro-entrepreneurship, increasing spending in local businesses, and attracting tourists who might not otherwise visit. In Barcelona, Airbnb guests spent an estimated €740 million in 2016, supporting over 7,000 jobs in the city.

C. Study by the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER): A study published by NBER in 2019, titled "The Economic Effects of Airbnb Expansion," examined the impact of Airbnb's expansion on the U.S. economy. The study found that Airbnb's growth led to increased tourism spending, job creation, and income growth in local economies. It also found evidence that Airbnb helped alleviate hotel capacity constraints during peak seasons and special events, thereby supporting the tourism industry and promoting economic resilience.


2. Flexibility for Travelers: Short-term rentals offer travelers more flexibility in terms of accommodation options compared to traditional hotels. They provide a home-like environment with amenities such as kitchens and living spaces, making them especially appealing for families, groups, or long-term stays.

3. Promotion of Tourism: Short-term rentals can help promote tourism in a city by providing unique and diverse lodging options for visitors. This can attract a wider range of travelers and enhance the city's reputation as a tourist destination.

4. Cultural Exchange: Hosting short-term rental guests can facilitate cultural exchange and foster connections between visitors and local residents. Guests can experience the city from a local's perspective, gaining insights into the community's culture, traditions, and way of life.

Drawbacks?

1. Housing Affordability: Short-term rentals can contribute to housing affordability challenges by reducing the availability of long-term rental housing units. Property owners may opt to convert residential properties into short-term rentals, leading to a decrease in housing supply and increased competition for available units, which can drive up rental prices.

A. Study in the United States: A study published in the Journal of Urban Economics in 2020 analyzed the impact of Airbnb on housing prices in the United States. The researchers found that a 1% increase in Airbnb listings in a ZIP code led to a 0.018% increase in rental prices and a 0.026% increase in house prices. The study suggested that Airbnb listings contribute to higher housing prices, especially in neighborhoods with high demand for short-term rentals.

B. Study in New York City: A study conducted by researchers at McGill University and published in the Journal of Economic Geography in 2020 examined the impact of Airbnb on rental prices and housing affordability in New York City. The study found that Airbnb activity led to a 1.4% increase in rental prices and a 3.2% increase in housing prices in neighborhoods with high Airbnb density. The researchers also found evidence of displacement of long-term residents in neighborhoods with high Airbnb activity.

These studies provide empirical evidence of the impact of short-term rentals on housing price inflation in various urban contexts. They suggest that the proliferation of short-term rental platforms like Airbnb can contribute to higher housing prices, especially in neighborhoods with high demand for short-term accommodation. However, it's important to note that Saratoga Springs differs from other major urban environments in the United States. To date, no study has been conducted to evaluate the impact short-term rentals have on the Saratoga Springs housing market.

2. Neighborhood Disruption: Short-term rentals can disrupt residential neighborhoods by bringing in transient guests who may not have the same investment in the community as long-term residents.

3. Community Impact: While short-term rentals contribute to the city's tourism industry and economy, they also have implications for the local community. Some residents express concerns about the impact of transient guests on neighborhood character, noise levels, parking availability, and housing affordability.

Summary:


The tradition of renting homes to tourists in Saratoga Springs reflects the city's heritage as a beloved destination with a vibrant tourism industry. While this practice offers economic benefits and lodging options for visitors, it also raises important considerations about community dynamics and quality of life for residents. Finding a balance between tourism promotion and responsible housing practices remains a key priority for Saratoga Springs as it continues to welcome guests from near and far.

369 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page